MadTracker.org
MT2 Compo
 Back

Salt

By Toa

Yannick

Originality:8Theme:7Arrangement:6
Technical:6Quality:6Global:7
Well, the least I can say is that it is quite an uncommon track.

The author rendered a dramatic atmosphere quite well. However, it quickly starts to get repetitive.
The main theme is good. But it misses something else to accompany. Perhap using this string drama theme as a refrain and having couplets would work better. With vocals maybe?..

The author seems to be in the middle of a FT2-MT2 conversion. :) All the samples are from .XI files, so they have a wrong original sample rate (fixed at 8363 Hz) and need tuning to get the pitch correct. That can lead to slight sound distortion.

Good work. Now try to build more around a theme. ;)


Sunbuster

Originality:3Theme:7Arrangement:3
Technical:3Quality:4Global:4
Going for the demo-scene type thing here I think. A very dramatic tune, but repetitive.

The drums are very simple, and they could use more variation. It feels as if one drum pattern was created and that then copied to most other patterns.
The lead melody sounds a bit force, and I think it's because of the samples used to play it. They sound a bit strung out.
Samples seem to be of pretty low quality, but at least it's the same all the way through.

Good about this tune is the dramatics. And I think it could work pretty well as a demo-tune. But it's too repetitive.


D.Copy

Originality:6Theme:2Arrangement:3
Technical:3Quality:3Global:3
Terminator's Return!
The impression - is not present an ideological line, but the pain and despair which the author in a composition wanted to transfer is traced.
Interesting idea, but underfulfilled.


Netbeat

Originality:7Theme:6Arrangement:6
Technical:6Quality:8Global:6
Style: soundtrack,orchestral-classic,electro. bombastic sounds. very nice theme - with powerfull, classical theme. a bit more variations would do a lot. keep it up!



Copyright © 1998-2005 Yannick Delwiche
All rights reserved