MadTracker.org
MT2 Compo
 Back

Land of Nothinghill

By TmX / Altered Reality

Yannick

Originality:9Theme:8Arrangement:7
Technical:7Quality:6Global:9
Very nice mix of celtic music and pop-rock. Very energic and catchy.

The guitars sound really great. However, almost all the samples are 8-bit mono. You still could have increased the file size a bit. Too bad...

The structure of the song is good. Everything happens at the right moment.

Very good work. More of this! ;)


Sunbuster

Originality:6Theme:7Arrangement:8
Technical:7Quality:6Global:8
That lead that starts after about 1:20 has an extreme "I've heard it before" feeling over it. Just can't place where I've heard it...

The tune has a pretty nice energy to it when it's playing at it's best (and this comes from a trance-person). Instrument pannings are pretty good. The drums could have been placed a bit more carefully I think. Now only the hihat has been shifted noticeably to one channel. You could for instance have placed the snare further into the other channel to balance it out a bit.

Overall, pretty nice, like the sliding effect on the guitars also.


Daniel

Originality:8Theme:8Arrangement:8
Technical:7Quality:7Global:9
Good try for life like guitars.
Very nice sliding effects.
A real originality in this compo, and an unexpected development of the main theme.
The choice of synthetics wind instruments is a little weird, but it sounds in the finish like a celtic modern production.
Good job means good rating.


Thomas

Originality:4Theme:4Arrangement:5
Technical:7Quality:7Global:5



D.Copy

Originality:8Theme:5Arrangement:6
Technical:6Quality:3Global:6
Ок.
About this composition it is possible to tell much, but at once it would be desirable to note bad quality of tools.
Such impression, that biggest level of a sound.
About ideologically point of view it is very beautiful, but realization of arrangement spoils impression.
At magnificent idea (celtic ethnic), very mediocre work above the general sounding.
It would be desirable to hear more sated and solemn sound.
There is a smeared line of a theme. There is no definiteness.
The impression - a beautiful and competent composition, but probably did not suffice the author of time or opportunities релизовать it completely.


Netbeat

Originality:9Theme:9Arrangement:9
Technical:9Quality:9Global:8
style: 1. romantic folk - later pop-rock! interesting folk-song. the elec.dist.guitarsample could be better nevertheless one of the gonna be winner-tracks! one of my favourite cause:

1.real theme /main melody + improvisations
2.original
3. groovy , real "drummer like" feeling
4.with climax

keep it up, professional!




Copyright © 1998-2005 Yannick Delwiche
All rights reserved