Color scheme

 
MadTracker.org
MT2 Compo
 Back

Le Marabout

By Jean-Charles Vidal

Sunbuster

Originality:7Theme:3Arrangement:5
Technical:4Quality:6Global:4
I don't quite know how to categories this. Interesting to some extent, but boring. There isn't enough going on to make it really interesting. Seems to be a random collection of drums, some pads, a disted guitar, and couple of fx sounds.

The bongos are barely audible, they could use a bit more volume.
The vocal snippet is pretty cool, it fits the mood of the tune well. What I also appreciate is that the drums seem to be pretty random. Not much of that copy/paste from one pattern to another in other words. The melody that is played by the organ is pretty cool also.
What I dislike is the sound of the disted guitar, it somehow doesn't fit the rest of the tune IMO. The use of instrument 0E isn't very good either. It sounds a bit forced, as if the author thought "I must have another submelody playing here" and then couldn't come up with something that fit the tune better.

Conclusion, an interesting tune, but it lacks the little things.


Daniel

Originality:8Theme:3Arrangement:9
Technical:6Quality:6Global:7
Hu?
Original with good arrangements. But that's all in my point of view.


Thomas

Originality:7Theme:7Arrangement:7
Technical:6Quality:7Global:7

A great track! Has a great theme. Only thing I see could be tweaked would have to be the sounds themselves. Some could use more treble 'cause some have a "closed" sound. Other than that great job!


D.Copy

Originality:1Theme:1Arrangement:2
Technical:2Quality:2Global:2
Well concerning this track it is difficult to tell something... The Discord is observed so frequently, that the impression of musical illiteracy and absence of the idea of a track is created.


Netbeat

Originality:9Theme:8Arrangement:4
Technical:3Quality:8Global:7
style: experimental, psycho-dark. slow groove.very original, sounds some times like a movie-track! cool sounds , nice effects included. this author really knows how to produce atmosphere - this one suggests a deep, dark atmosphere! the elec-dist-guitar has a wrong tuning - has to be finetuned!


Copyright © 1998-2005 Yannick Delwiche
All rights reserved